The Bianca Devins Tragedy, Netflix Censorship, 25 Most Influential Internet People, Puerto Rico Leak

  • Опубліковано 16 лип 2019
  • Go to or text PHILLYD to 500-500 to get started today!
    The Limited-Time Over/Under Drop is LIVE! Some items are starting to sell out, so run, don’t walk!
    Watch the latest PDS!:
    Watch the latest Bonus News video!:
    SUBSCRIBE to DeFrancoDoes:
    Follow me for the personal stuff:
    Need more news? Find more stories here:
    Support this content w/ a Paid subscription @
    Follow Me On:
    Today in Awesome:
    Check out for 47% off “Beholder 2” only available until 9 AM!
    How Your Tax $$ Pays For Luxury Homes & more:
    Casual Explainer, but Serious Gamer:
    Insane Ways People Smuggled Things Into Prison:
    Can you solve the dark matter fuel riddle?:
    Emma Chamberlain Tries 9 Things She's Never Done:
    Inferno Wing Challenge from Regular Show:
    Drama Actors Roundtable:
    Secret Link:
    Today’s Stories:
    Netflix Edits 13 Reason Why:
    National Suicide Prevention Lifeline: 1-800-273-8255
    International Suicide Prevention:
    Protests in Puerto Rico:
    #RIPBianca Trends on Twitter:
    TIME’s Most Influential People on the Internet:
    More News Not Included In Show Today:
    VidCon Apologizes to Miles McKenna:
    Thousands of Facebook Users Pledge to Storm Area 51:
    Louisiana Declares State of Emergency as Residents Brace for Tropical Storm Barry:
    R. Kelly Facing Two New Federal Indictments:
    Labor Secretary Alex Acosta Resigns Over Epstein Plea Deal:
    Call to End Discrimination Against LGBTI Soldiers in South Korea:
    Politician Tells Reporter She Must be Accompanied by a Male Colleague:
    Edited by: James Girardier, Julie Goldberg
    Produced by: Amanda Morones, Brian Espinoza
    Art Director: Brian Borst
    Writing/Research: Philip DeFranco, Lili Stenn, Maddie Crichton, Sami Sherwyn
    #DeFranco #Netflix #TIME


  • Philip DeFranco
    Philip DeFranco  Місяць тому +2869

    I'm quitting the internet for the rest of the day after today's show. See you tomorrow and here are today's timecodes: 13 Reasons Why Edited Scene Out (0:23), Influential People (4:37), TIA (5:46), Puerto Rico Leaks & Protests (8:07), Bianca Devins (12:38)

    • Eduardo Rivera
      Eduardo Rivera 26 днів тому

      Can you quit the internet forever, please?

    • Cynical Citizen
      Cynical Citizen Місяць тому

      Have a good day sir

    • Maccoy Johnson
      Maccoy Johnson Місяць тому

      but people have released videos with information about the things she was doing that caused her death.

      She emotionally abused mentally-ill men
      she also said on multiple accounts that she wanted to die
      She had rape fantasies that she talked to mentally-ill men about on discord as well. she was leading them on until this happened
      Apparently she got what she asked for.
      It may not have been what she deserved, but it's what she wanted (based on what she says and does on discord and stuff)

    • mongrel m
      mongrel m Місяць тому

      Your quitting the internet for the 'day' oh STFU MAN NO ONE GIVVES TWO FUCKS U MORON

    • christina flowers
      christina flowers Місяць тому

      I’m the book 13 reasons why she takes pills 🤔 if I remember correctly

  • Cassie Marie
    Cassie Marie 2 дні тому

    Big Heckin Group of Dang Doggos on facebook. Having a bad day? Pupper pictures. Having a great day? Pupper pictures. Very supportive group made better by dogs.
    But in reality, this show. This is where I go to get news, it covers things you don't hear about otherwise. Also The Daily Show with Trevor Noah.

  • TalliCat Games
    TalliCat Games 3 дні тому

    You say that...but I am alone. I have to be.

  • Crab Jr
    Crab Jr 4 дні тому

    I am a survivor of my own attempt on my own life, hearing the scene depicted triggered my anxiety, though I have to say that is the desired effect I believe many people need in order to make a change in the world. If not for the hard feelings, there would be little push and motivation for change. 13 reasons why brought up the issue, better to have it than to not have it. Though this is coming from someone who has not seen it, would be too hard for me to watch

  • GyroMurphy
    GyroMurphy 4 дні тому


  • Muzagucci
    Muzagucci 6 днів тому

    bianca also identified as asexual and that may be a factor as to why the man acted out- as she denied his advances.

  • skillustrate
    skillustrate 7 днів тому

    Censoring the Netflix episode was a powerful decision- they've just guaranteed that that scene will get even OVERWHELMINGLY more attention than it already had. Genius.

  • RFOC2
    RFOC2 7 днів тому

    Suicide while it is horrible and sad is nothing more than the cowards way out of a bad situation... Fight me on this one I have seen more death and self destruction , Then any of you little shits can comprehend.

  • Mia Torres
    Mia Torres 7 днів тому

    the scene scared me it was just bad and they need to edit out the scene where the one dude gets a broom shoved up his butt and his face smashed into the sink and the scene where hannah gets raped

  • MyLifeAsErica
    MyLifeAsErica 8 днів тому

    It’s strange to me that the book had been around for years and no one complained about it until it was turned into a Netflix series. I remember when it was in talks of being a movie first. So if you had a problem with it glorifying suicide then you should have said something about the BOOK before the tv show. They also changed the death from taking pills to wrist cutting for the fact that taking pills is always romanticized when it comes to suicide where wrist cutting is not.

    I think it needed to stay because it makes you uncomfortable, it makes you see that it’s not a simple cut and you fade away and all the pain is gone. It hurts, you are suffering, and it’s not instant. Then you see the suffering of the family finding her.
    If someone wants to kill themselves a tv show won’t make them if they already had their mind made up about it. Helping, listening, and looking for signs are the only way to truly help someone, not editing a show.

  • Jesse Ringle
    Jesse Ringle 9 днів тому

    Joe rogan
    Phillip defranco

  • cece
    cece 9 днів тому

    did he just call me a bastard -

  • blake moneé.
    blake moneé. 10 днів тому

    yo honestly that 13rw scene was SO hard to watch i don't even think i watched the whole thing lmao i'm pretty sure i closed i eyes idk , i'm just not into gory stuff. i think it's dumb they took it down but like also i love how they did it 3 seasons later bc everyone has already seen it so it doesn't really matter haha so props to them for that i know they did that on purpose haha tbh people are just too sensitive nowadays and also hypocrites like the same people saying suicide is "glamorized" are the same ones saying that scene was "too graphics" but also we as a society need to "start a conversation" lol so like okay ... what do u want? if someone wants to kill themselves they're going to do it no matter what. no one who isn't suicidal is going to watch that and be like "hannah baker slit her wrists and died so *I* slit my wrist and died haha so quirky". people are so dumb this is the equivalent to people saying putting gay characters in kids shows/movies will turn their kids gay. now that i think bout it, they're probably the same ones saying 13rw make ppl kill themselves lol stfu

  • Kevin J
    Kevin J 11 днів тому

    Sad about Bianca death but man looking into this is just sad, and all the people she played with online and IRL. RIP

  • Laura Iturralde
    Laura Iturralde 13 днів тому

    Personally, that scene made me realize how horrible self harm looks. When you are doing it to yourself you don't realize the implications, but seeing it on someone else made me feel disgusted at myself and it showed me how it appears on the outside, making me come to terms that I never wanted to be in that position. I get the controversy behind the scene, but I believe that it's the only scene where suicide is not glorified.

  • Ashley Marie
    Ashley Marie 13 днів тому

    I think that showing what actually happens when you decide to cut yourself with the intention to bleed to death was pretty damn important. As someone who has been through the moment of looking in the mirror, and suicide went from an idea to a decision. I think showing what it looks like was so important to me. It was supposed to hurt. It was good to cry for Hannah, and for her Mother. I think the problem with "glorifying" came with the tapes. Odds are, Zach wouldn't have been the good guy... There would not be these people going crazy over the tapes. Clay wouldn't have been the way he was. It created the idea that if you kill yourself people will stop everything.. it was just too much. The part that pissed me off was when the lady had washed Hannah's dress.
    ?: Did 13RW remove the rape scenes?

  • F.Y.E AMVs
    F.Y.E AMVs 13 днів тому

    Seriously? You’re gonna highlight that garbage about the pewdiepie statement? I don’t understand why they even mentioned that in the buzzfeed article because it literally has nothing to do with this.

  • JustPassingThrough
    JustPassingThrough 14 днів тому

    Sadly, I am actually quite unsurprised by the Bianca Davis story. I've seen a SHARP increase in outright disdain for women among my male peers. And the worse part, the statements heralding these changes get "likes" in the THOUSANDS. I used to hear people talk about this issue in the past and thought they were just fear mongering. Even if that was true then, it certainly isn't now. There is, without a doubt, a seriously substantial circle of young men who outright hate any woman not on her knees begging to be with them. So gals. Be ready to fight. And get smart about these ensuing threats. I don't see this issue going away anytime soon. And people who know these kinds of guys? Talk to them. They will only continue farther down these dark paths unless they are otherwise diverted. Oh and to all the guys out there who have a general distaste for females for whatever reason? Grow the fuck up. Yeah there are a lot of shitty gals out there. There's also a lot of shitty guys. But there's far more people worth being on good terms with than not. Oh and news flash. Being "rejected" by a lot of gals is not cause to decry them as a whole. It might mean you need to get your shit together. It might mean you just need to keep looking. It's probably both. Either way, it's absolutely NO one's fucking responsibility to be with you. But also, to gals who lead guys on for whatever reason? You better cut that shit out. I don't care what kind of daddy issues you had, some random guy does not deserve to suffer for it. By no means is physical violence warranted in those situations, but when you fuck with someone's emotional well being like that... well you better fucking be ready for what comes next.

  • JustPassingThrough
    JustPassingThrough 14 днів тому

    Well alrighty then. Looks like it's time for the higher ups of Puerto Rico to be replaced. I want Roseo on the streets without any sort of political power whatsoever. Frankly, I think that country would do far better outside of U.S. jurisdiction, but that's a conversation for another time. For now, the highest levels of Puerto Rican power could use the same treatment as those of the U.S... a complete flush out.

  • JustPassingThrough
    JustPassingThrough 14 днів тому

    I am disappointed with Netflix's decision here. The scene should have remained. It is exactly as Chrei Levesque put it. It SHOULD be scarring. Not for shock value. But to remind people of the ugly reality that is killing yourself. It is one of the few parts of 13 Reasons Why that I have no qualms about.

  • slapchop14
    slapchop14 16 днів тому

    Say a news anchor from Puerto Rico was delivering news about New York, and every time they said New York they broke from their natural, normal Spanish cadence to pronounce "NOOO YAWK", wouldn't you think that anchor was a fuckin weirdo? No one, literally no one expects people who don't speak their language to awkwardly mangle the pronunciation of their country/city/territory/village etc. in the middle of otherwise normal sentences. I'm sure Phil could give a rat's ass about my opinion, but these are the types of things that always makes me feel like he's pandering to his audience. It's unnecessary and inauthentic. I realize that "what me, I'm just a normal dude just trying hard" is his schtick, and I know that despite this schtick he likes to project the "I've paid my dues and don't care what you think about me" attitude, but damn I wish he'd cool it on the brown-nose type stuff. Phil, you've carved out an unmistakably important niche. I think your influence it not to be denied. And it's a tremendously positive influence. But knock of the annoying shit!!!
    P.S. We all know how to use UAplus Phil. Stop asking us to comment with our opinions on topics way too nuanced for most of us to be commenting on! Lol...I know it helps you make money, but it just encourages idiots to vomit verbal diarrhea about complex topics they've literally JUST heard about!!!
    Ok. That's enough. Have a wonderful weekend.

  • Mashmakhan
    Mashmakhan 16 днів тому

    Pewdiepie #1 influencer

  • jenn lemmelin
    jenn lemmelin 16 днів тому

    God you are annoying. I'm never watching this show again

  • MintSodaOWO
    MintSodaOWO 16 днів тому

    I think they should have kept the suicide scene in the show because it shows that suicide isnt pretty and its painful. Instead of the suicide scene being edited maybe they could have edited in season 2 the male sexual assault scene considering that scene made me sick to my stomache. They honestly should have just leaved the show alone

  • Vanna Meyers
    Vanna Meyers 16 днів тому

    I'm a 19 year old female, I watched 13 reasons why about three times. This may be sad, but I was heavily abused by my mother from the ages of 9 to 15. I was sexually assaulted by a distant family member. In 2017 I finally had the nerves to tell my mother that I was assaulted by my distant family member. In the summer of 2018, my mother watched 13 reasons why by herself, after she finished watching the series she walked into my room and hugged me apologizing for all the things she did in the past. Because of 13 reasons why I became closer to my mother. I don't think it's fair that these big organization has a say in what Netflix should and shouldn't do with series. Until these organization show statistics of teenages killing themselves from watching 13 reasons why, I do not think it's fair.

  • Marlena thorvald
    Marlena thorvald 17 днів тому

    Oh the Washington Post tried to link this tragedy to PewDiePie I'm so surprised

  • BeyondTheLizzy
    BeyondTheLizzy 17 днів тому

    Most Influential for me would be:

  • sorucha
    sorucha 17 днів тому


  • Trident True
    Trident True 18 днів тому

    Thank you so much! I'm so happy to see this opinion being voicemail I was afraid to say otherwise online, but I thought 13 Reasons Why was he absolutely amazing show and allowed me to express the type of trauma and fix extreme emotion you feel when dealing with some real thoughts of suicide and depression not just the kind of surface-level depression most teens seem to go through no offense. I know a lot of people craps on the show but never before the show had I been able to relate with the character so well.
    The fact that you would take such a impactful and meaningful seeing is abhorring to me it makes me sad to be honest I can absolutely understand that it's triggering to some viewers and I would never want to do that to someone. But I wish that maybe there was a way to have alternate versions of the show? Like a tractors cut and a regular cut. Because I really do think that's something that's not worth getting rid of four people that wants to experience something like that. I'm a very drastic an emotional person so for me that wasn't scary that was like experiencing a high or something.

  • Gage Mcribins
    Gage Mcribins 18 днів тому

    I thought the show sucked

  • ITZ Kittycat
    ITZ Kittycat 18 днів тому

    The olive garden mom on Instagram, her name is Karen and she does Facebook lives on topics shes mad about and shes very inspirational

  • riley n
    riley n 18 днів тому

    bianca also had a mental illness

  • Intuitive Duck
    Intuitive Duck 19 днів тому

    People want attention, fame, status, power, & money. Healthy people know where to draw the line. Sick people seek more & more will never be enough... That is where obsession can lead you. I feel so bad for that poor girl.

  • Intuitive Duck
    Intuitive Duck 19 днів тому +1

    "Ricky Leakes!" 🤣🤣🤣

  • Intuitive Duck
    Intuitive Duck 19 днів тому

    I love watching Ben Shapiro. I get a ton of news in like, 5 minutes. Lol. He talks so fast & I like his opinions.

  • Elena Sweetapple
    Elena Sweetapple 19 днів тому

    John Oliver for managing to inform me and change my mind about things that I was firm on (like the death penalty)

  • Jake38nine
    Jake38nine 19 днів тому

    "Please let her rest peacefully." Is a joke. People "respect" the dead and yet also exploit the dead. There is no "resting peacefully" in their sense. People "respect" the dead more than they respect the living. It's a joke.
    Maybe I don't have a lot of trust in the people around me to respect my wishes when I die, so I just have the mentality that once I'm dead it doesn't matter what happens to my body because I will have no consciousness of what happens to it.

  • Gary Parker
    Gary Parker 19 днів тому

    Any list of "Most Influential People on the Internet" that doesn't include Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson is just out of touch.

  • Brenda Hernandez
    Brenda Hernandez 19 днів тому

    Phil, what are some audiobooks that's you've listened to that you would recommend?

  • Jaimie Smith
    Jaimie Smith 19 днів тому

    I love how passionate you are! It’s appreciated

  • aLeX ThOtSlAyEr
    aLeX ThOtSlAyEr 21 день тому

    Ben Shapiro is amazing ❤️

  • hinata167
    hinata167 21 день тому

    Jon Stewart

  • gretchenishere
    gretchenishere 22 дні тому

    Leonardo DiCaprio, Phillip DeFranco, Trevor Noah and Eminem are probably very influential for me. But generally that always depends on which content one is exposed to at the time.

  • Jennifer Henriquez
    Jennifer Henriquez 23 дні тому

    Dr. Mike is very influential.

  • JamlessJiminie
    JamlessJiminie 23 дні тому

    BTS is easily the most influential people in my life, my role-models and the way they've impacted my life is immeasurable. their lyrics and videos, the work they put in everything they do, the way they love and care for each other and their fans so much, all of it's a lot, i love them a lot

    • JamlessJiminie
      JamlessJiminie 21 день тому

      Lissie Lamb with all due respect, that's really stereotypical. kpop as an industry has many flaws, as does hollywood, and as does the american music industry. and unfortunately, many groups are used as collateral for larger companies. but this is NOT true for all of these groups. they are people, whether the public or their companies view them as that or not, and they are not cogs in a machine. bts help millions of people, with their music or with their donations and though in the spotlight for 7+ years, they've remained humble and thankful for the success they've achieved. they're changing the kpop industry for the better.

    • Lissie Lamb
      Lissie Lamb 21 день тому

      That's nice but don't forget how grueling the lime light is on K pop stars. They are cogs in a machine

  • Raw Corn
    Raw Corn 23 дні тому

    Sponsors and ads on a video about a girl getting killed wow...

    • CJ
      CJ 21 день тому +1

      Well yes, this is his job and it's a news show, he shares good and bad news.

  • marianna clutter
    marianna clutter 24 дні тому

    Joe Rogan, You're self and Anna Akana have for sure made some of the biggest impacts for my self.

  • Annie Le
    Annie Le 24 дні тому +3

    The story of Bianca Devins happened in my hometown and the news quite literally blew up nationally. Bianca recently graduated from my school this past June and although I never personally knew her, I somehow felt such a strong connection to her death. Her vigil was beautiful and I'm glad her story is bringing up awareness. If you are able to, her family has set up a scholarship fund in her name in which you are able to donate here:
    Bianca wanted to attend our local community college and study psychology so that she could help others. This scholarship will help those who are aspiring to do the same thing. Thank you for any donations and please spread the word

  • Chika Mika
    Chika Mika 24 дні тому

    In regards to Netflix editing out the suicide scene in 13 reasons why, I think it's not only to late, but pointless to take it out in my opinion. I had to turn away halfway though the scene because I felt sick, but only because I'm not great at looking at blood. It was actually the rape scenes in season 1 that affected me the most, especially the final one, in my opinion I saw those scenes more graphic (despite not showing any genitalia) than the suicide scene. I think this is because of what I have been a victim of in the past, so my take on it will definitely be different from another person take on those scenes.

  • Alice Oh
    Alice Oh 24 дні тому

    Phil needs to dig deeper into the Bianca’s story. The way the headlines are and the misconceptions makes this about “don’t talk to strangers on the internet” and this isn’t it. It’s about mental illness and not a gender war. Everyone is so focused on saying men are trash and it’s firing up all this outrage for the media which covers the truth.
    1. He was not a stranger, he even met her family.
    2. She was fucking multiple guys, emotionally manipulate and abuse them
    3. She sends nudes to guys to threaten them to pay or else she will report them because she’s underaged
    No she did not deserve to die, but you cannot report a false story. This is important because everyone is using this story as an example of why men are trash when it should be a story that reminds us why mental health awareness is important.
    If a guy sleeps with, threatens and emotionally abuse multiple girls and get killed, would there be the same outrage? No.

  • Alannah Anne
    Alannah Anne 24 дні тому

    Shane Dawson should be on that list bro he's so inspired

  • hoshi.hoshh h
    hoshi.hoshh h 24 дні тому


  • Forrest L
    Forrest L 25 днів тому

    I like this guy Phillip DeFranco. He is my primary source for the need to knows. Keep up the great work!

  • Forrest L
    Forrest L 25 днів тому

    i appreciate you Phil

  • (X̥̥̥﹏X̥̥̥`*)
    (X̥̥̥﹏X̥̥̥`*) 25 днів тому

    update: a few minutes ago, june 24th, ricardo rossello has presented his resignation as Governor of Puerto Rico effective august 2nd, 5PM EST
    he will be succeded by secretary of justice, Wanda Vazquez

  • WieloAlpaca
    WieloAlpaca 25 днів тому

    We did it bois,Ricky resigned,This is history

  • Catherine Hawkwind
    Catherine Hawkwind 25 днів тому

    The Bianca story is crazy. The people who think she was in the wrong are scary fucking people. People like the guy who killed her. Their mindsets are fucked up.
    People are so desperate for fame they’ll share a body? Disgusting. Truly.

  • Hope Carreira
    Hope Carreira 25 днів тому

    But.. where’s the Phillip DeFranco theme song? ❤️

  • Whitney K
    Whitney K 25 днів тому +2

    As a Puerto Rican, I appreciate your trying to say “Puerto Rico” with an accent. 👍🏻❤️

  • Levi Ramsey
    Levi Ramsey 25 днів тому

    I have serious mixed feelings about 13 reasons why. In one hand, raising awareness and challenging stigmas of mental health and suicide is a really good thing. On the other hand, I cannot help but think it is capitalizing on pain and suffering. It seems to me, to glorify suicide, to encourage it, to present it as a viable option for escape. I'm not offended by the scene just the theme and intention of such a film. When Logan Paul filmed the suicide forest we all agreed he is a piece of crap for making money off suffering. When it's an entertaining netflix show, we make excuses and argue.

  • Kryssy Thorne
    Kryssy Thorne 25 днів тому

    I have had two family members kill themselves and I watched the show with my kids I believe although shock ING it needs to be out there the pain that is left behind is as real as watching that scene but in real life ...there are reality tv shows that show worst stuff that actual real life I'm from Australia and think it was one of the best shows I have ever watched as someone personally been effected by suicide

  • kickdocable
    kickdocable 26 днів тому

    The way you said ‘Puerto Rico’ laugh so hard. But it was cute

  • Mark Chang
    Mark Chang 26 днів тому

    11:46 Puerto Rico is one of many US territories. It is not a country.

  • Kalypso Kat
    Kalypso Kat 26 днів тому

    The same assholes who say "she had it coming" often enough are the same ones all butthurt and offended when a woman does try to be safe and careful. They then go "I'm not a creep. You dont have to worry about me."

  • Kevin Wilson
    Kevin Wilson 26 днів тому

    They need to take out the scene where someone got a broom shoved into their ass

  • Savant Lady Lilith
    Savant Lady Lilith 26 днів тому

    As someone who cut and attempted suicide, seeing that scene was powerful and has made urges happen less. Seeing it happen to someone else and begging them not to do it may have changed my life and they are ruining it. These people are oblivious to how it feels to be in that kind of pain.
    Also...I love you too Phil. You are an amazing human being and deserve only the best things to come your way ♡♡

  • Megan Fast
    Megan Fast 26 днів тому +1

    When I watched the scene where hannah killed herself, i didnt realize what it would fully show, I was at a vulnerable state and decided what I had to after. I stole blades from my work, like her, and just dreamt of the relief that was on her face once she died.
    I refuse to watch any of it now, especially after hearing what happens in season two. My 16 year old brother in law watched and all he did was make jokes, and almost everyone else I know doesnt take the show seriously, it's just a shock value thing.

  • Chris Shawgo
    Chris Shawgo 26 днів тому +1

    BTS is most influential for me. As an adult who found fangirling late in life, I can say it was worth the wait. These guys are so talented and hard working, but more importantly they are humble, genuine, and they care very much for their fans. You just don’t see that very often. And plus, here I am, learning a new language! That’s a win.

  • Michael Cotta
    Michael Cotta 26 днів тому

    The gruesome nature of the scene in 13 reasons why showed the reality of suicide and I feel like editing it out takes away from it. People need to realize that there is no easy way out and that despite how it seems like it is fast and easy, the only way out is over time. There is no reason for a permanent solution to a temporary problem. While it may not feel temporary everything gets better with time and self care. Not a condemnation of anything in regards to that story I just feel like it should've been left the way it was shot. Every episode ended up having a warning in the beginning of the episode. I'm sure Netflix has a handle on how to shoot their shows and will continue to watch it even though it is a difficult show to watch

  • Laurie B
    Laurie B 26 днів тому

    I think it’s great the scene was removed cause, being someone that’s been suicidal, it made it look easy. Like the cut was painful but then you go to sleep. It showed the right way to cut to successfully kill yourself. It scared me. But I think it’s honestly too little to late, cause it was able to be viewed for over 2 years now.

  • Falcon777
    Falcon777 26 днів тому

    God this video was a cluster fuck of emotions.
    Story 1: I have not seen the series, I have been haunted by thoughts of suicide since I was a teen. I can't judge if the show is good or bad without seeing it (in the sense of morality), but that said I think removing anything after the fact does not help the narrative that you were trying to paint, especially with something this controversial.
    Story 2: Dwayne Johnson, INcontrol (may he rest in peace), Jessie Cox are 3 celebrities that have influenced me.
    Story 4: It is not surprising to hear about this, but still sad. I know there is more to the story in a later video, but just blah, I have friends from Puerto Rico and they don't deserve the crap the local government is doing to them (I mean in general no one does, but yeah)
    Story 5: As for the PoS who killed Bianca, world would have been better off if he had just died. He doesn't deserve a chance at life, even behind a prison cell. That is just too good for him. As far as

  • Frederick Thorne
    Frederick Thorne 27 днів тому +1

    thanks for continuing to boldly talk about the hard to talk about subjects, Phil.

  • Sonya Willis
    Sonya Willis 27 днів тому

    8:08 that sexy pronunciation!

  • Sean Davis
    Sean Davis 27 днів тому

    Phil, why didn't you also talk about how Bianca was a self-described whore that used guys and didn't give a fuck about them?

  • Sharky Overlord
    Sharky Overlord 27 днів тому

    The five people I consider most influential in my internet experiences are:
    1. Markiplier
    2. Jacksepticeye
    3. Game Grumps
    4. You, Phil ❤️
    5. Matpat and other theorists (especially cat dad Nick Nocturne 💚💜)

  • Rikku Sayian
    Rikku Sayian 27 днів тому

    why isnt phil on the 25 list???????

  • Rikku Sayian
    Rikku Sayian 27 днів тому +4

    for the 13 reasons thing you should ask survivors of suicide they would be the best to ask

  • Phi phi
    Phi phi 27 днів тому +1

    13 rw actually triggered me tbh, i know i shouldn’t have watched it but everyone told me to so i did for a bit, it triggered every bad thought i used to have and was like a trigger for me to attempt suicide again, it really does romanticise suicide and i hate it, after this my cousin committed suicide and i had to go through that whole deal while 13 rw was coming out with a new series, It just completely shapes suicide wrong, people are sad for a while then they move on but the people closest to the person who died never forget and are changed forever, you don’t become a national hero for committing suicide, you’re literally just gone and have left the people who love you broken forever.
    The show puts a narrative in depressed peoples minds that if they die they’ll become famous or everyone will honour them, it is far from the truth.

  • uaedaien
    uaedaien 27 днів тому

    Leaking messages from a private chat should be a crime.

  • kim kon
    kim kon 27 днів тому

    I feel like Will Smith, Shane Dawson, John Oliver, Rihanna, Michelle Obama and Beyoncé are very influential to me

  • Daisy O'Brien
    Daisy O'Brien 27 днів тому

    Regarding 13 Reasons why, for me I found it horrific but something to learn from. I've never felt that low and as much as people telling me about it would help me to understand, visually seeing it made me feel the severity of depression and I have more knowledge on the subject. However a friend of mine who has been in that place and knows how it feels and the triggers that it can cause thinks it should have never been allowed on television. The scene is powerful but dangerous if you're not in the right place to view it, I can see it from both sides.

  • Ben Mc Dermott
    Ben Mc Dermott 27 днів тому +7

    Didn't suicide rates between youths rise by like 40 percent they really shouldnt keep making the show

  • Zhou Xi
    Zhou Xi 27 днів тому

    Can INCELS be designated as terrorists now?

  • Ian Denner
    Ian Denner 27 днів тому

    If anybody wants to commit suicide a tv series won't nudge them further into the dark... they are already there!

  • TheGameFreak013
    TheGameFreak013 27 днів тому

    16:12 what part of the story implies that this incident had anything to do with sexual advances? until theres evidence that suggest it truly was the case, you cant just use this incident to throw half the population of the human race under the bus

  • Cody Shipley
    Cody Shipley 28 днів тому

    Hey Phil, my friend and executive chef was one of the pallbearers. Thank you for respecting their wishes.

  • theycallmejodamo
    theycallmejodamo 28 днів тому

    I don't think they should have edited the scene.... Just like actual suicide, it's meant to be unpleasant and graphic. Stop sheltering people from reality and claiming it glamourizes the act of suicide.... People need to see how things impact others. Stop pretending it doesn't exist/happen.

  • Lea Redding
    Lea Redding 28 днів тому

    huh, interesting how the puerto rican governer said some insulting sexist/homophobic stuff... and then the people demand for his resignation. Yet Trump can basically do whatever he wants, says whatever he wants, and no one does anything...

    • Little Goobster
      Little Goobster 27 днів тому

      No one does anything? People were calling for Trump to he impeached as well. There has also been plenty of uproar from the general public.

  • 안녕
    안녕 28 днів тому

    13 Reasons Why was a B rated suicide. It wasn’t even good. I thought it was gonna be more graphic since everyone was making a big deal out of it. You gotta be stupid to follow along a tv show.

  • Rachel S
    Rachel S 28 днів тому

    I don't think they should have removed the suicide scene. It didn't glorify suicide at all. It showed how real it was and how serious suicide and the events leading up to that moment are to thousands of struggling teens around the world. You can't have those events play out leading up to the scene and then cut away to the reaction from her parents. If anything this takes the gut wrenching sad reality away from the scene and will trigger more people who otherwise would have reconsidered their own suicidal feeling after seeing these terrible events in their entirety. I think we shouldn't shy away from these issues and art and film have always reflected what is happening in our everyday lives. I applauded 13 reasons why for not cutting away and not sugarcoating this very REAL, very SERIOUS problem. Keep it in, it will help more people than it offends.

  • Tdog
    Tdog 28 днів тому

    honestly, the show euphoria seems to do what 13 reasons why tried to do it seems like

  • Saghar Ghezel
    Saghar Ghezel 28 днів тому

    There is so much more to the bianca story. Please delve deeper if you can.

  • TheNovelNovelist
    TheNovelNovelist 28 днів тому +2

    I really think it ought to be pronounced "R-I-P" rather than "rip"...especially in a story featuring a victim who was STABBED to death.

  • Emelie Hartikka
    Emelie Hartikka 28 днів тому

    As a suicide survivor who watched the show I think the depiction was accurate, which is important to me. But the most moving part was her parenting coming in. The part with her parents entering was also edited which I think was a mistake. It wasn’t too graphic and it should have remained unchanged even if the actual suicide was cut. I have respect for health care professionals as well as other survivors and people currently suffering. But the scene with her parents was so moving. And editing it takes away from the point of the scene. As other people have said. The glorification of suicide in 13 reasons why was not from that scene. But the over all idea of the show. That you could somehow have a large impact after your dead and not have to live with the consequences. Which in most cases is not true.

  • I have no name
    I have no name 28 днів тому

    Those waste of fucking oxygen people spreading Bianca's dead body pictures are going to rot in hell.

    May her family have the peace of mind they rightfully need. And may Bianca's soul rest in peace.

  • Sofi Nabeel
    Sofi Nabeel 28 днів тому

    Wait... where’s Pewds on the TIME list?!

  • Tabby Hil
    Tabby Hil 28 днів тому

    You’re amazing

  • Shmeediddy
    Shmeediddy 28 днів тому

    Violoent movies of people getting glorified killed. No shock
    A high school fictional girl commit suicides, everyone loses their minds...

  • Rachael Clarke
    Rachael Clarke 28 днів тому

    I will forever defend 13 Reasons Why. The book was one of the reasons I am alive today because it forced me to look at the impact my suicide could have on everyone around me, even those i never realized thought much of me. It helped me see light in a very dark time over 10 years ago. I loved that the original show had such graphic content. It's startling, upsetting, triggering, and honest and I think that it's sometimes necessary when talķing about suicide. It's not peaceful for anyone, it's terrifying and painful and creates the most horrifying ripple in the world around you. That being said, with that scene in the show, I don't believe everyone should watch it and I plan on rewatching the episode to see what they did instead. I don't actually have strong opinions on the removal of the scene, but I'm glad I got to cry through the original.

  • Emily Marlow
    Emily Marlow 28 днів тому +1

    Pretty sure Hannah died through a medication overdose in the original book therefore making the graphic scene in the bathtub inaccurate to the story. It also makes it seem like the show’s producers wanted to add drama and controversy around the series.